Greatest MLB Centerfielder Ever

361 Votes · Published on November 1, 2019

All Voters

1
Willie Mays
1951-1973 (22 seasons) • 3283 hits, 660 home runs, .302 batting • WAR: 156.4 • 2x MVP, 20x All-Star
100.0
60 Votes
0
2
Ty Cobb
1905-1928 (24 seasons) • 4189 hits, 117 home runs, .366 batting • WAR: 151 • 1x MVP
86.4
53 Votes
0
3
Mickey Mantle
1951-1968 (18 seasons) • 2415 hits, 536 home runs, .298 batting • WAR: 110.3 • 3x MVP, 16x All-Star
75.3
47 Votes
0
4
Tris Speaker
1907-1928 (22 seasons) • 3514 hits, 117 home runs, .345 batting • WAR: 134.1 • 1x MVP
62.8
37 Votes
0
5
Ken Griffey Jr.
1989-2010 (22 seasons) • 2781 hits, 630 home runs, .284 batting • WAR: 83.8 • 1x MVP, 13x All-Star
60.0
37 Votes
0
6
Mike Trout
Since 2011 (9 seasons) • 1324 hits, 285 home runs, .305 batting • WAR: 72.5 • 2x MVP, 8x All-Star
56.9
37 Votes
0
7
Joe DiMaggio
1936-1942, 1946-1951 (13 seasons) • 2214 hits, 361 home runs, .325 batting • WAR: 78.1 • 3x MVP, 13x All-Star
49.7
29 Votes
0
8
Duke Snider
1947-1964 (18 seasons) • 2116 hits, 407 home runs, .295 batting • WAR: 66.4 • 8x All-Star
30.8
21 Votes
0
9
Kirby Puckett
1984-1995 (12 seasons) • 2304 hits, 207 home runs, .318 batting • WAR: 51.1 • 10x All-Star
23.3
15 Votes
0
10
Kenny Lofton
1991-2007 (17 seasons) • 2428 hits, 130 home runs, .299 batting • WAR: 68.3 • 6x All-Star
21.1
12 Votes
0
11
Carlos Beltran
1998-2017 (20 seasons) • 2725 hits, 435 home runs, .279 batting • WAR: 69.6 • 9x All-Star
16.9
10 Votes
0
12
Andruw Jones
1996-2012 (17 seasons) • 1933 hits, 434 home runs, .254 batting • WAR: 62.8 • 5x All-Star
0.0
3 Votes
0

Who is the greatest of the two?

Vote on Another Matchup »