Greatest MLB Left Fielder Ever

217 Votes · Published on November 2, 2019

All Voters

1
Ted Williams
1939-1942, 1946-1960 (19 seasons) • 2654 hits, 521 home runs, .344 batting • WAR: 123.1 • 2x MVP, 17x All-Star
100.0
33 Votes
0
2
Barry Bonds
1986-2007 (22 seasons) • 2935 hits, 762 home runs, .298 batting • WAR: 162.8 • 7x MVP, 14x All-Star
99.0
33 Votes
0
3
Stan Musial
1941-1944, 1946-1963 (22 seasons) • 3630 hits, 475 home runs, .331 batting • WAR: 128.2 • 3x MVP, 20x All-Star
91.3
31 Votes
0
4
Rickey Henderson
1979-2003 (25 seasons) • 2295 hits, 297 home runs, .279 batting • WAR: 111.2 • 1x MVP, 10x All-Star
81.6
27 Votes
0
5
Carl Yastrzemski
1961-1983 (23 seasons) • 3419 hits, 452 home runs, .285 batting • WAR: 96.4 • 1x MVP, 18x All-Star
66.0
24 Votes
0
6
Manny Ramirez
1993-2011 (19 seasons) • 2574 hits, 555 home runs, .312 batting • WAR: 69.4 • 12x All-Star
60.2
19 Votes
0
7
Tim Raines
1979-2002 (23 seasons) • 2605 hits, 170 home runs, .294 batting • WAR: 69.4 • 7x All-Star
40.3
15 Votes
0
8
Al Simmons
1924-1944 (20 seasons) • 2927 hits, 307 home runs, .334 batting • WAR: 68.8 • 3x All-Star
34.0
11 Votes
+1
9
Ed Delahanty
1888-1903 (16 seasons) • 2597 hits, 101 home runs, .346 batting • WAR: 69.7
31.1
10 Votes
-1
10
Billy Williams
1959-1976 (18 seasons) • 2711 hits, 426 home runs, .290 batting • WAR: 63.7 • 6x All-Star
24.3
9 Votes
0
11
Willie Stargell
1962-1982 (21 seasons) • 2232 hits, 475 home runs, .282 batting • WAR: 57.5 • 1x MVP, 7x All-Star
13.1
5 Votes
0
12
Lou Brock
1961-1979 (19 seasons) • 3023 hits, 149 home runs, .293 batting • WAR: 45.3 • 6x All-Star
0.0
0 Votes
0

Who is the greatest of these two?

Vote on Another Matchup »