Greatest MLB Shortstop Ever

632 Votes · Published on October 24, 2019

All Voters

1
Honus Wagner
1897-1917 (21 seasons) • 3420 hits, 101 home runs, .328 batting • WAR: 130.8
100.0
93 Votes
0
2
Alex Rodriguez
1994-2016 (22 seasons) • 3115 hits, 696 home runs, .295 batting • WAR: 117.8 • 3x MVP, 14x All-Star
86.4
82 Votes
0
3
Cal Ripken Jr.
1981-2001 (21 seasons) • 3184 hits, 431 home runs, .276 batting • WAR: 95.9 • 2x MVP, 19x All-Star
71.9
72 Votes
0
4
Robin Yount
1974-1993 (20 seasons) • 3142 hits, 251 home runs, .285 batting • WAR: 77.3 • 2x MVP, 3x All-Star
61.4
57 Votes
0
5
Ernie Banks
1953-1971 (19 seasons) • 2583 hits, 512 home runs, .274 batting • WAR: 67.5 • 2x MVP, 11x All-Star
55.9
58 Votes
0
6
Derek Jeter
1995-2014 (20 seasons) • 3465 hits, 260 home runs, .310 batting • WAR: 72.4 • 14x All-Star
48.8
52 Votes
0
7
Arky Vaughn
1932-1948 (14 seasons) • 2103 hits, 96 home runs, .318 batting • WAR: 72.9 • 9x All-Star
45.4
44 Votes
0
8
Ozzie Smith
1978-1996 (19 seasons) • 2460 hits, 28 home runs, .262 batting • WAR: 76.9 • 15x All-Star
42.6
44 Votes
0
9
Barry Larkin
1986-2004 (19 seasons) • 2340 hits, 198 home runs, .295 batting • WAR: 70.4 • 1x MVP, 12x All-Star
35.4
39 Votes
0
10
Alan Trammell
1977-1996 (20 seasons) • 2365 hits, 185 home runs, .285 batting • WAR: 70.7 • 6x All-Star
35.2
39 Votes
0
11
Luke Appling
1930-1950 (20 seasons) • 2749 hits, 45 home runs, .310 batting • WAR: 74.5 • 7x All-Star
27.3
28 Votes
0
12
Joe Cronin
1926-1945 (20 seasons) • 2285 hits, 170 home runs, .301 batting • WAR: 66.4 • 7x All-Star
6.6
14 Votes
0
13
Pee Wee Reese
1940-1958 (16 seasons) • 2170 hits, 126 home runs, .269 batting • WAR: 66.3 • 10x All-Star
0.0
10 Votes
0

Who is the greatest of the two?

Vote on Another Matchup »